What’s your arguing style?
What’s your arguing style?
Six questions, about a minute. Built from the patterns readers say they recognised in themselves.
For reflection, not diagnosis. Most people are a mix.
The Lawyer
When a concern comes up, you reach for evidence: what they did last month, the pattern, the precedent. It feels like fairness. To the other person it feels like their one small point just got buried under a trial.
A reader who recognised the same pattern:
“Whenever my partner brought up a frustration, my instinct was to pull up an alibi: “Well, you did that last month too”. The author calls this out plainly: defending your entire character instead of answering the one small concern in front of you. Just dropping the “always” and “never” made our discussions wrap up in ten minutes instead of spiraling until midnight.”
Start with the chapter on defensiveness. It’s one of 24 short chapters in On Your Side Again, each with a reusable page. More readers on this →
The Explainer
You’re not trying to win. You just need them to understand why it happened. The trouble is that a list of reasons, offered first, lands as “so it wasn’t really my fault”.
A reader who recognised the same pattern:
“I used to think I was just “explaining context” whenever my husband raised an issue. The book showed me that listing reasons why I did something is just defensiveness wearing a reasonable disguise. Acknowledging the impact before offering an explanation changed everything.”
Start with the chapter on defensiveness. It’s one of 24 short chapters in On Your Side Again, each with a reusable page. More readers on this →
The Vanisher
When it gets too hot you need out, and that instinct isn’t wrong. What hurts is the open-ended silence afterwards, when nobody knows if or when the conversation comes back.
A reader who recognised the same pattern:
“Taking a break during a fight never worked for us because taking a break meant someone was walking out and disappearing for 24 hours. Requiring the person who asks for space to name an exact check-in time removed the panic completely. We haven’t had a door-slamming fight since.”
Start with Pause and Return. It’s one of 24 short chapters in On Your Side Again, each with a reusable page. More readers on this →
The Scorekeeper
You track who did what because you want things to be fair. But a running tally turns every favour into a debt, and every weekend into a negotiation.
A reader who recognised the same pattern:
““I drove to your parents’ house last weekend, so you owe me Saturday morning.” We had this exhausting mental spreadsheet going on for years. This book showed us how toxic tit-for-tat bargaining really is and helped us look at what a fair week actually feels like for each of us.”
Start with the chapters on sharing the load. It’s one of 24 short chapters in On Your Side Again, each with a reusable page. More readers on this →
On Your Side Again
- Physical book · 24 chapters · 24 reusable pages
- Order 2 or more and get printable A4 worksheet PDFs
- 90-day returns
Why we built this from reviews
When readers describe what changed for them, the same four habits keep coming up: building a case, explaining, disappearing and keeping score. None of them makes you the villain. They are what most people do when they feel accused. The book’s approach, in one reader’s words: “It gives you systems instead of guilt trips.”
Keep the idea. Get the other 23 chapters.
On Your Side Again has a short chapter and a reusable page for 24 everyday moments like this one.
Get On Your Side Again →90-day returns · Order 2+ for the printable worksheet PDFs
Read all 330 reader reviews, including the 3-star ones